The Constitutional Underclass: Gays, Lesbians, and the Failure of Class-based Equal Protection Book + PRICE WATCH * Amazon pricing is not included in price watch

The Constitutional Underclass: Gays, Lesbians, and the Failure of Class-based Equal Protection Book

The Constitutional Underclass : Paperback : The University of Chicago Press : 9780226288604 : 0226288609 : 01 Apr 1999 : Using Colorado's initiative with Amendment 2 as its focus, this text seeks to untangle the complex standards and subtle rhetoric the Supreme Court uses to apply the equal protection clause. It reveals how these standards are used to favour certain groups over others.Read More

from£20.99 | RRP: £12.50
* Excludes Voucher Code Discount Also available Used from £9.41
  • Amazon Review

    Gays and lesbians have long been the targets of legal discrimination (think of the 1986 Supreme Court Bowers ruling upholding antisodomy laws, Colorado's Amendment 2 banning gay rights legislation, the federal Defense of Marriage Act, and so on), and all efforts to pass legislation that would give them the same protections given to other minorities such as blacks and women have failed. For the time being, says Evan Gerstmann, gays and lesbians facing discrimination "can only win by appealing to judicial sympathy and intuitions about fairness rather than by invoking any coherent legal principle." But, he continues, the struggle for class-based gay and lesbian rights should not be considered an issue unto itself, but should be looked at within the entire field of "equal protection" jurisprudence. In that context, we learn that the courts have been reluctant to expand the boundaries of class-based protection to include any new group in more than two decades. Gerstmann's legal analysis is detailed and informative, and his conclusion--that it may be more profitable in the long run for activists to focus on rights involved rather than on their own identities--is provocative. --Ron Hogan

  • Product Description

    When the Supreme Court struck down Colorado's Amendment 2—which would have nullified all state and local laws protecting gays and lesbians from discrimination—it was widely regarded as a victory for gay rights. Yet many gays and lesbians still risk losing their jobs, custody of their children, and even their liberty under the law. Using the Colorado initiative as his focus, Gerstmann untangles the complex standards and subtle rhetoric the Supreme Court uses to apply the equal protection clause.

    The Court divides people into legal classes that receive varying levels of protection; gays and lesbians and other groups, such as the elderly and the poor, receive the least. Gerstmann reveals how these standards are used to favor certain groups over others, and also how Amendment 2 advocates used the Court's doctrine to convince voters that gays and lesbians were seeking "special rights" in Colorado.

    Concluding with a call for wholesale reform of equal-protection jurisprudence, this book is essential reading for anyone interested in fair, coherent, and truly equal protection under the law.

  • 0226288609
  • 9780226288604
  • E Gerstmann
  • 22 February 1999
  • Chicago University Press
  • Paperback (Book)
  • 206
  • 2nd
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. If you click through any of the links below and make a purchase we may earn a small commission (at no extra cost to you). Click here to learn more.

Would you like your name to appear with the review?

We will post your book review within a day or so as long as it meets our guidelines and terms and conditions. All reviews submitted become the licensed property of www.find-book.co.uk as written in our terms and conditions. None of your personal details will be passed on to any other third party.

All form fields are required.