The Silence of Sodom: Homosexuality in Modern Catholicism Book

The Silence of Sodom is a smart, graceful, important book about homosexuality and modern Catholicism. Its author, Mark D. Jordan, is a professor of theology at Emory University. Significantly, the book's main point transcends discussion of sexual identity. The point is that theology cannot, fundamentally, be argued; it must be lived. "Serious moral theology cannot be principally the framing and manipulation of quasi-legal propositions. It must begin and end in the discovery of particular lives under grace". Consequently, Jordan writes, "Lesbian and gay lives will have to become audible to the church, readable within it, before their graces can be discerned and described". The way for gay lives to become audible in the church, Jordan argues, is to demonstrate an intimate relationship between "homosexuality and holiness that is, human fullness". To demonstrate that relationship requires that gay people reconceive their notions of identity by questioning the descriptive power of terms such as "gay" and "homosexual", and perhaps even abandoning such terms. Gay Catholics, Jordan says, "should feel contrition for having pretended to have a sexual identity, when what we had were desires, memories, and loves. To be good homosexuals is, for Catholic men, to conspire with our old persecutors in a sin against ourselves. The homosexual is only the sodomite in approved drag". Abstruse jargon, sloppy thinking and excessive pride are common pitfalls for writers who address simultaneously the subjects of Christianity and homosexuality. Jordan avoids all of these dangers. In plain language, with humility, he gently insists that readers join him in learning how to talk about sexuality and physical pleasure in a way that amounts to talking about Christian love. --Michael Joseph GrossRead More